Topside Minis Product Review

Topside Minis Product Review

Hello again! Today, I take a detailed look at a product that I am quite excited about: Topside Minis.  I feel that this product represents an important development  for naval wargaming, making it much easier for gamers to get into the hobby. Topside Minis (TM) has been a going concern for a couple of years now, and in that time the company has been steadily expanding its range of ships and aircraft.

imageLate last year, TM initiated the biggest expansion to their inventory yet via a Kickstarter campaign. This campaign focused on the Atlantic and Mediterranean theaters of WWII. Naturally, I jumped into this in a big way, and my long-awaited package arrived not long ago! So I figured the time was right for an in-depth look at these minis.

Description

Essentially, TM are two dimensional markers that consist of a laser-cut wood base and an adhesive label with artwork that depicts a specific ship or aircraft. However, there is a big difference between a traditional chit marker and a TM. Whereas traditional markers tend to be very bare-bones, the artwork on a TM is simply beautiful. Small details are worked into each one, to include wakes, smoke coming from funnels, aircraft sitting on catapults, and the like. And best of all, there are slight differences in these details between ships of the same class, helping players to tell them apart and adding more visual interest. These differences could be in the markings, deck coloration, or even the train angle of the main battery turrets.

image

Here is the TM of the WWI German cruiser Scharnhorst (top), next to a more “traditional” marker of the same ship.

Scale

These minis are a good size; the founders of TM, John Czarzasty and John Giacchino, are big fans of Axis & Allies War at Sea, and have made the ships to the same scale as the minis in that game (about 1:1800). As a result, the larger battleships and carriers are a handful, about 6 inches long by an inch and a half wide! TM renders their aircraft at 1:450, presumably to allow for greater detail in the artwork. However, the aircraft are still only about an inch to an inch and a half on a side, so I don’t expect they will take up too much room on the table.

Assembly

image

Assembling a TM is very straight forward; you are essentially putting a sticker on a piece of wood. However, there is a few things to keep in mind. First, the artwork comes printed on sheets with multiple ships on each sheet. Each individual ship has to be cut from that sheet, as they do not come pre-cut. This is not hard to do, of course, but it can be a bit tedious (especially when you have a couple of hundred ships to do!). Additionally, some care must be taken to avoid over-trimming each ship, and with placing the labels on their wood bases. I’ve found that using a guillotine-style cutter and making long cuts on full sheets of paper make this whole process much more efficient. Additionally, I’ve found that if I have an alignment problem, I can carefully peel the label back off the base and it will still have enough stickyness to it that I can try again. And, I’ve inevitably cut a few of mine too small, which leaves a sliver of bare wood showing along one or more edges of the label. This doesn’t look terrible, and probably would be fine to leave as-is. However, that sort of thing brings out my modeling OCD, so what I’ve done in these cases is to use a blue permanent marker to color in the bare wood, which helps camouflage the mistake. I suppose one could also get the same effect by base coating the wood bases in black or dark blue before assembly.

Selection

Right now, TM boasts over 800 units in its range. With the release of the Atlantic and Mediterranean sets, TM now has a mini to cover the majority of the major warships which took part in WWII. They are also beginning to expand into the WWI timeframe; a limited number of WWI German and British ships are available, mainly from the early battles of the war. In the works is a set that will cover all the ships both sides had at Jutland! The company has not quite gotten to the point where it has universal coverage of all the famous ships for the war; the Iowa-class battleships, for example, are missing from the lineup. Likewise, some large classes, like the Essex class carriers, do not have all their sister ships available yet.

Value

I cannot say with certainty that TM are the least expensive option out there for naval gaming models, but they have to be close. Units range in price from $0.40 U.S. for destroyers, all the way up to $2.20 for large battleships. In addition to being available individually, players also have the option to purchase sets that cover specific battles or theaters. This makes it handy to grab a good selection of units to match what you might be interested in. So, for around $50-$100, you can easily get a couple of good-sized fleets that will give you plenty of gaming fun. As discussed above, these minis look great, and their plywood construction makes them quite durable.

Conclusion

As you can probably tell, I’m a big fan of TM. These things look great, are highly cost-effective, and seem like they will hold up to years of use. Now, that being said, they may not be for everyone; after all, while these are great looking markers, they are still not full-fledged 3D miniatures.  Additionally, while the variety of ships and aircraft types available is impressive, there are still some holes in the lineup waiting to be filled (such as the Iowa class). Still, if you are looking to dip a toe into WWII or WWI naval gaming, or, like me, are looking for a secondary set of minis that are easier to move and transport, TM deserve some serious consideration!

 

This entry was posted in Review and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to Topside Minis Product Review

  1. Pingback: Man Battlestations Monthly Newsletter 16 |

  2. avatar Jake says:

    I solved the problem of wood showing on the finished mini (due to over cutting or a slightly messed up attempt at applying the label sheet to the wood) by using a black Sharpie marker to tidy it up after assembly. You can email me and I’ll send you some pictures of before/after to show how it comes out.

  3. avatar fcm says:

    I give them an “A” for effort because they do look as nice as any 2D counters I’ve seen, but the value proposition kinda sinks it for me. They want $60 for what is essentially a stack of stickers with some flat chunks of wood. IMHO they need an alternative fit for the 21st century, which would be to make downloadable PDFs available for a much lower price. Then I can print them out at will and mount them on whatever I feel like, without worrying about choosing the right ships, or damaging them by accident, or lengthy shipping times.

    • avatar Ruckdog says:

      Thanks for your comment, fcm! Value is, of course, in the eye of the beholder; to me, the convenience of having every thing printed out already and supplied with correctly sized bases is worth the cost, but I can definitely see where you are coming from. I recommend you provide your feedback directly to TS Minis, as it really is just a two-man show. I’ve found them very responsive in the past, and I’m sure they would be glad to hear from you. Cheers!

    • avatar Mike C says:

      These are great “stickers” as you call them. What was not mentioned is that they are made on a 2 mil self-sticking vinyl and therefore, extremely durable. Printing them on paper would be a weaker quality and tear easily.
      As for price, there is not a better quality, nor cheaper way of making a good selection of any size naval fleets. I’ve spend many $$$ for worse product. I wish these were out there years ago.

  4. Pingback: Check Out Andy Rucker’s Review of His TSM Atlantic Kicktarter Set |

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *